Bayley`s Ice Cream in Scarborough

Great ice cream, friendly service.

Great ice cream

Cheerful, friendly service that curbside service during pandemic.

I often wonder how this place can be so underrated....The crabmeat roll was as scrumptious as could be served on a warm, toasted bun. Truly excellent O rings and clamcakes as well !

When they opened the window to take our order, a delightful aroma filled the air. The hardest part was selecting what flavor, but everything was delicious. Can't wait to go back.

These girls that work here are the best. The ice cream is superb...so many different flavors..be prepared when you order a small it's just like having a large. We go there when ever we are in Maine...which is 3 times a year.

Ice was delicious and quick service 😊

Great ice cream and tons of choices. Triple chocolate truffle is perfect for the chocoholics!

What a treat! So many flavour options! And all of the girls working had a great attitude, even with the constant line of about 10 people at 8pm! Great Ice cream place!

Friendly staff, yummy ice cream.

They have THE best ice cream!! No matter the flavor you will be happy with your choice. The portions are good size so you won't feel jipped. Enjoy!

We enjoyed our ice cream...

Very nice people quick service and homemade ice cream. Close to home.

Lots of flavors. The sundae was great.

Our favorite ice cream place in the Scarborough area. Great ice cream, good portions. If you are looking for the best ice cream come here.

Awesome service! Crazy big selection of flavors and very reasonable prices!

Best icecream and great service the portions are also above expectations

Excellent! Lots of unique flavors

So good. Creamy and rich, it's one of our favorite places to stop after spending a day at the beach. I love their grasshopper ice cream (mint with Oreos) and if they have it, my son loves their peppermint stick.

One of the few places you will find who put real fresh strawberries on their ice cream sundae! Great local place with a huge list of flavors and great ice cream!

Lots of flavors. The kids liked it.

Gluten free cones

My favorite ice cream place. Good portion size, lots of flavors. Both soft and hard. My favorite flavors orange pineapple, black cherry chip.

Ice cream was really good!

Compare this place with the Dairy corner I would say they are similar in prices but you get more icecream at Bayleys. There is no big line at bailey and I think because they have faster employees than Dairy corner. Very good icecream

Went there for some ice cream after going to the marsh, the dairy free cookies n creme was very good.

Yogurt ice cream IS lactose tolerable! Huge blessing, as I say if we only had one choice of food, I want ice cream! HA!

Great ice creme. Creative flavors

The lemon soft serve is so good!

Excellent customer service! Bayley's ginger ice cream is AMAZING!!

Ice cream was very good

Great ice cream

Lots of flavors. The kids loved it. Watch for the mosquitoes in the evening.

You like ice cream; you'll love Bayley's. Homemade ice cream in generous servings. I'd be inclined to say too generous -- I couldn't finish my medium cup of soft serve, and my husband gave up on his cone about halfway through. Mind you, it's GOOD ice cream, but next time, I'll remember to order the small.

Visited for the first time tonight and Bayley’s did not disappoint! Everything we tried was fantastic...coffee toffee fro-yo, coffee heath bar ice cream, payday ice cream, and vanilla soft serve. We arrived just in time. When we turned around after placing our order the line was massive! I will say we received our order in about 5 minutes and there are plenty of benches and picnic tables for seating.

Tradition for us to come to when visiting the area. Large selection of soft and hard serve. Great portions and a staff that wants to help. Management has to be doing something right to be this consistent all these years.

Best ice cream in Maine. There are so many flavors to choose from. Rich and creamy flavor.

Very Good Ice Cream and Great Staff! Rest Rooms are located at their Fried Clams Restaurant next door.

Really good made on site ice cream

Great ice cream, lots of it for a great price.

Great Treats and Service

Bayleys was really good and i bet that the homemade cones are amazing. I had maple walnut and one taste was all i needed to know this place was good!

I've lived in Scarborough for 3 years, we love this place for their ice cream. But they NEVER have DIPPED waffle cones.. it's been 2 years since I've gone and they actually had them. And in the summer we go weekly. I know it's silly, but I usually end up not getting anything because I cant get a dipped cone.

Lots and lots of flavors. All delicious. We tried 4 between my wife and I and they were yummy.

Coconut Almond Bar hard ice cream is TO DIE for! Carmel & peanuts only help. Great place.

Soft serve was amazing, but the waffle cones had holes in the bottom and broke easily. I would definitely go back for some ice cream but no more waffle cones.

Worth a stop after some clams or clam cakes next door at Bayley Seafood.

So many flavors and soooo delicious!!!

Still has orange-pineapple and butter almond crunch, very good flavor selection

Ice Cream was delicious.